Fidelity HSA vs Lively HSA
Choosing the right Health Savings Account (HSA) for investing can significantly impact your long-term healthcare savings, especially as W2 employees with HDHPs or self-employed individuals look to maximize tax advantages. Many individuals fear missing out on potential growth or falling victim to hidden fees, which can quickly erode investment gains. With contribution limits constantly on the minds of families and financial advisors, selecting a provider that offers robust investment options without excessive costs is paramount. This comparison will delve into two leading contenders, Fidelity HSA and Lively HSA, to help you determine which offers the best hsa for investing, ensuring you're not leaving money on the table or risking an IRS audit due to poor management.
Fidelity HSA
Fidelity HSA stands out as a top choice for individual investors looking for a robust and cost-effective platform. It boasts $0 maintenance fees, $0 transfer fees, and requires $0 minimums to open an account or begin investing.
Lively HSA
Lively HSA is recognized for its exceptional accessibility and transparent fee structure, making it another strong contender for the best hsa for investing. Like Fidelity, Lively charges $0 account and transfer fees, with no minimums required to open an account.
| Feature | Fidelity HSA | Lively HSA |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Maintenance Fees | $0Tie | $0Tie |
| Minimum to Open Account | $0Tie | $0Tie |
| Minimum to Invest | $0Tie | $0 (Schwab), $0 (Devenir)Tie |
| Investment Platform & Options | Fidelity's brokerage (stocks, ETFs, mutual funds)Winner | Schwab brokerage (stocks, ETFs, mutual funds) or Devenir guided |
| Investment Platform Fees | $0Winner | $0 (≥$3K Schwab), $24/yr (<$3K Schwab), 0.5% (Devenir) |
| Transfer Fees | $0Tie | $0Tie |
| Customer/Industry Recognition | Top Morningstar 2025 ratings, 4.4M+ accountsWinner | #1 for accessibility/no fees |
Our Verdict
For individuals and families seeking the absolute best hsa for investing, Fidelity HSA often emerges as the frontrunner. Its unwavering commitment to $0 fees across the board—no maintenance, no transfer, and no investment platform fees regardless of your balance—combined with $0 minimums to open and invest, makes it incredibly accessible and cost-effective.
Best for: Fidelity HSA
- Individual investors prioritizing the lowest possible fees with no minimums.
- Active investors seeking a wide range of stocks, ETFs, and mutual funds.
- Those who prefer a single, integrated platform for all their investment needs.
- Users who want to consolidate multiple HSAs without transfer fees.
Best for: Lively HSA
- Individuals who already use Schwab for other investments and prefer a unified experience.
- Employers or individuals seeking strong accessibility and user-friendly features.
- Those who might benefit from a guided investment approach (Devenir option).
- Users who anticipate maintaining an investment balance of $3,000 or more to avoid Schwab fees.
Pro Tips
- Don't just save, invest: The industry average for invested HSAs is only 7-10%. Make sure your HSA funds are growing, especially if you have a comfortable cash buffer for immediate medical costs.
- Look beyond the monthly fee: Some providers waive fees with a minimum cash balance. Factor in potential investment platform fees or trading costs, especially for smaller balances, as with Lively's Schwab option below $3,000.
- Consolidate multiple HSAs: If you've had several employers, you might have multiple HSAs. Consolidating them into one provider, especially one with $0 transfer fees like Fidelity or Lively, can simplify management and potentially lower fees.
- Prioritize investment flexibility: If you're an experienced investor, seek providers offering a wide range of stocks, ETFs, and mutual funds. If you prefer a hands-off approach, look for guided investment options.
- Consider the long game: An HSA is often called the 'triple-tax advantaged' account for a reason. Maximize contributions and invest for retirement healthcare costs, a significant pain point for many.
- Check for auto-substantiation features: For employers or those managing family plans, features like HealthEquity's 85-95% auto-substantiation can significantly reduce administrative burdens and fear of audit.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the key eligibility requirements for opening an HSA?
To be eligible for an HSA, you must be covered under a High-Deductible Health Plan (HDHP) and not be enrolled in Medicare, nor be claimed as a dependent on someone else's tax return. Your HDHP must meet specific deductible and out-of-pocket maximum thresholds set by the IRS annually. For example, for 2026, while specific limits aren't yet available, the principle remains: you must have an HDHP to contribute to an HSA.
How do HSA contribution limits work, and what are the 2026 amounts?
HSA contribution limits are set by the IRS each year and depend on whether you have individual or family HDHP coverage. These limits are a combination of employee and employer contributions. While the exact 2026 limits for individuals and families are not yet specified in recent regulatory changes, it's crucial for account holders to stay informed as exceeding these limits can lead to penalties.
Can I invest my HSA funds, and what are the typical investment options?
Yes, one of the primary benefits of an HSA is the ability to invest your funds, allowing them to grow tax-free. Most HSA providers offer a range of investment options, including stocks, ETFs, and mutual funds, similar to a traditional brokerage account. Some, like Lively, offer access to Schwab brokerage, while Fidelity offers its own extensive brokerage platform.
What are the common fees associated with HSA accounts, especially for investing?
HSA fees can vary widely among providers and are a significant concern for individuals looking to maximize their investment returns. Common fees include monthly maintenance fees, investment platform fees, and transfer fees. For instance, Fidelity HSA boasts $0 maintenance and transfer fees, with $0 minimums to open or invest. Lively HSA also offers $0 account and transfer fees, but its Schwab brokerage option might incur a $24/year fee if your investment balance is below $3,000.
How does an HSA differ from an FSA, particularly regarding investment potential?
An HSA differs significantly from a Flexible Spending Account (FSA) in several key ways, most notably regarding investment potential. HSAs are owned by the individual, are portable, and funds roll over year to year, allowing for long-term investment growth. FSAs, on the other hand, are typically employer-owned, are not portable, and often operate on a 'use-it-or-lose-it' basis, with limited rollover amounts, making them unsuitable for investment.
Are there specific HSA providers better suited for employers versus individual investors?
Yes, some HSA providers are better equipped to handle employer-sponsored plans, while others excel for individual investors. HealthEquity, for example, is noted as best for employers and large plans, offering features like 85-95% auto-substantiation and a robust platform. Benepass is also employer-focused, showing higher investment usage among its members (25%+ vs. 7-10% industry average).
Related Resources
More HSA Resources
Compare your own HSA options
Track and compare your healthcare costs in HSA Trackr. See where your money goes.
Start Tracking