Lively vs Fidelity
Fidelity holds 4.4 million HSA accounts, yet Lively's zero-fee model and $0 investment minimum are reshaping how individuals maximize tax-advantaged healthcare savings. If you're carrying an HDHP and a 2026 contribution limit of $4,300 for individuals or $8,550 for families, your choice of HSA provider directly impacts whether you're paying unnecessary fees or compounding wealth through self-directed investing. This best HSA providers comparison 2026 fees investment options guide cuts through marketing noise and compares the four dominant players by actual costs, investment access, and cash yields—so you can stop leaving money on the table.
Lively
Lively offers zero monthly fees, zero investment minimums, and access to over 13,000 mutual funds through Schwab's brokerage platform. With no hidden charges and low-cost Devenir funds, Lively attracts HSA holders who want transparent, frictionless investing without custodial gatekeeping.
Fidelity
Fidelity combines zero account fees with commission-free stock and ETF trading, fractional shares, and a 4.54% APR government money market yield (late 2023 baseline). As a top employer choice with 4.
| Feature | Lively | Fidelity |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly/Annual Account Fees | $0; no hidden feesTie | $0; no minimumTie |
| Investment Minimum to Start Investing | $0 minimumWinner | $0-$10 minimum |
| Cash Yield Rate (APY/APR) | Not specified; typical money market 0.1-0.5% | 4.54% APR government money market (late 2023 benchmark)Winner |
| Investment Options Available | 13,000+ mutual funds via Schwab; Devenir low-cost funds | Self-directed brokerage; stocks, ETFs, mutuals, commission-free; fractional sharesWinner |
| Administrative Investment Fees | $0; mutual fund expense ratios applyWinner | $0 self-directed; 0.35% AUM for managed accounts (optional) |
| Account Closure or Transfer Fees | Not specified; typical industry standard $0-$50 | $0 closure/transfer feesWinner |
| Employer Plan Integration | Direct employer support; customizable for groups | Industry-leading integration with 4.4M accounts; standard employer portalWinner |
| Brokerage Platform Features | Schwab brokerage access; mutual fund-focused | Native Fidelity platform; stocks, ETFs, options, fractional sharesWinner |
| Transparency & Hidden Costs | $0 stated fees; simple pricing modelTie | $0 stated fees; optional managed service disclosure clearTie |
Our Verdict
Choose Lively if you value fee transparency, $0 minimums, and want to avoid any hidden charges—ideal for self-employed individuals building HSAs from small monthly contributions. Choose Fidelity if you're a W2 employee with an HDHP willing to leverage commission-free stock trading and want the industry's highest cash yield (4.54%) for emergency reserves.
Best for: Lively
- Self-employed individuals fearful of hidden fees and IRS audits (Lively's transparent $0 structure provides mental clarity)
- HSA holders starting with modest balances ($500–$2,000) who want immediate investment access without minimum-balance lockouts
- Financial advisors recommending HSAs to fee-sensitive clients who demand zero-cost custodians
- Individuals prioritizing simplicity over features and seeking a 'set and forget' Schwab-routed mutual fund investment strategy
- HSA savers with strong convictions about specific low-cost Devenir funds or passive mutual fund allocations
Best for: Fidelity
- W2 employees with employer Fidelity 401(k) integration seeking seamless HSA payroll deduction setup
- Conservative HSA savers (age 50+) parking $5,000–$20,000 in emergency healthcare reserves to capture 4.54% cash yield
- Active individual stock traders wanting commission-free HSA stock purchases and fractional share rebalancing
- Families maximizing $8,550 annual contributions and planning 20+ year investment horizon with tax-loss harvesting needs
- Mid-market employers seeking a single-custodian 401(k)/HSA platform to reduce benefits admin burden
Pro Tips
- If your HSA balance exceeds $25,000, Fidelity's 0.35% managed account fee (capped value-wise) may cost less than Lively's mutual fund expense ratios if you hold expense-heavy actively managed funds. Calculate your fund's ER first.
- Lively's $0 investment minimum is a tax-loss harvesting advantage: you can sell a losing position with $500 and immediately redeploy to a similar low-cost fund without minimum constraints. Fidelity's fractional shares achieve similar outcomes with more flexibility.
- Don't leave cash in Lively's money market earning 0.1% if Fidelity's 4.54% yield is available. A $10,000 balance difference is $450/year in foregone yield. Confirm current rates before deciding.
- For W2 employees maximizing catch-up contributions at age 55+, Fidelity's commission-free trading allows you to dollar-cost-average monthly $1,000 catch-up deposits across low-cost ETF index funds without trading friction.
- HSA Bank and HealthEquity's investment minimums ($500–$1,000) create a hidden lock-out effect for balances under $3,000. If you're building from scratch, Lively and Fidelity's $0 minimums eliminate this gap-filling delay.
- Fidelity's fractional shares enable you to rebalance a $4,300 single-year contribution across 5+ asset classes without market-order timing risk. Lively requires full-share purchases, creating drag.
- Check your employer's plan: if Fidelity is the custodian through payroll deduction, you'll already have seamless employer contribution integration. Switching to Lively requires a trustee-to-trustee transfer, which is free but takes 5–10 days.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the 2026 HSA contribution limits, and does my provider charge fees on them?
For 2026, individual contributions cap at $4,300, family coverage at $8,550, with an additional $1,000 catch-up (age 55+). Lively and Fidelity both charge $0 on contributions regardless of size, meaning your full $4,300 or $8,550 enters the account without custodial deductions. HealthEquity charges $0 if your balance stays above $2,500; HSA Bank waives fees above $3,000.
If I'm self-employed and want to invest in individual stocks, which provider is better?
Fidelity wins for individual stock investors. Self-employed contributors can open a Fidelity HSA and buy stocks commission-free, reinvest dividends automatically, and sell partial shares without transaction fees. Lively routes stock orders through Schwab, which works but adds execution delays and requires you to open a linked Schwab account.
Does HSA Bank or HealthEquity offer better fees for family coverage above $25,000?
Neither beats Lively or Fidelity for large balances. HealthEquity charges $0 if balance exceeds $2,500 but imposes a $500 investment minimum and 0.03% annual investment admin fee (capped at $10/month). HSA Bank waives monthly fees above $3,000 but still charges 0.1–0.35% AUM for investing (waived only above $7,500 average cash balance). For a $30,000 family HSA, Lively's $0 fees with $0 investment minimum and Fidelity's $0 admin (optional 0.35% managed only) deliver superior economics.
Can I avoid IRS audit risk by using Lively's or Fidelity's auto-substantiation feature?
Neither Lively nor Fidelity offers integrated auto-substantiation (automated eligible-expense verification). HealthEquity leads here with 85–95% auto-substantiation rates, electronically confirming pharmacy and medical claims against IRS databases. Lively and Fidelity rely on manual receipt upload and your documentation.
I have $15,000 in my HSA and want to generate income without touching principal. Which provider's cash yield matters most?
Fidelity's 4.54% government money market yield matters significantly. A $15,000 balance earning 4.54% generates $682/year in interest, while Lively's estimated 0.1–0.5% yield generates $15–$75. Over 10 years, Fidelity's higher yield compounds to roughly $700 more in tax-free income. If you're using your HSA as a retirement income bridge (not a reimbursement tool), Fidelity's cash yield is a material differentiator.
Our company uses Fidelity for 401(k)s. Does that mean we should choose Fidelity for HSAs too?
Not necessarily, though Fidelity's integration is a convenience win. If your payroll system auto-enrolls employees in Fidelity 401(k)s, Fidelity HSA contributions can link to the same login, reducing admin friction. However, employer-side pricing for HSAs differs from 401(k) pricing. Fidelity may charge employers per-account fees or higher managed-account rates for HSAs than 401(k)s. Request a quote from Fidelity's benefits team and compare against Lively or HealthEquity's custom group pricing.
What's the real difference between HSA investment minimums of $0 (Lively/Fidelity) vs. $500–$1,000 (HealthEquity/HSA Bank)?
Investment minimums create a cliff effect. If you contribute $4,300 to HealthEquity but only $2,800 stays in cash (minimum $500 to invest), you earn near-zero yield on $2,800 while waiting to hit the $500 threshold. With Lively or Fidelity, that $4,300 immediately deploys across funds or stock. For savers building an HSA from scratch ($200–$500/month), Lively and Fidelity eliminate the 'dead money' period entirely.
I'm worried about fees eating into my HSA growth. Should I pick Lively or Fidelity based on your comparison?
Both deliver fee transparency. Lively's $0 account fees and $0 investment minimum are best for hands-off investors who want simplicity and want to avoid surprise charges. Fidelity's $0 account fees, commission-free trading, and 4.54% cash yield win for active traders or conservative savers parking emergency reserves. If you're afraid of hidden fees, Lively's messaging is more aggressive about zero hidden costs, which may provide peace of mind. Fidelity's optional 0.
Related Resources
More HSA Resources
Compare your own HSA options
Track and compare your healthcare costs in HSA Trackr. See where your money goes.
Start Tracking