Health Equity vs Fidelity HSA Checklist (2026) | HSA Tracker
Choosing between Health Equity and Fidelity for your HSA is a decision that can cost you hundreds in fees and limit your investment growth if you get it wrong. While both accounts offer the same core tax benefits under IRS Code Section 223, the details of fees, investment access, and cash management differ dramatically. This health equity vs fidelity hsa checklist is designed for W2 employees, self-employed individuals, and families who need a clear, actionable plan to select the right custodian for their healthcare savings and retirement goals in 2026. Use this step-by-step guide to avoid common pitfalls like hidden fees or missing out on investment opportunities.
Account Setup and Eligibility Verification
Before you compare features, confirm you can actually open and fund an HSA. This section ensures you meet the strict IRS rules and understand the basic account parameters that apply to both Health Equity and Fidelity. Missing a step here could lead to ineligibility and tax penalties.
Confirm you are enrolled in a qualified High-Deductible Health Plan (HDHP).
This is the non-negotiable foundation for HSA eligibility. Without an HDHP, you cannot contribute, regardless of which provider you choose. For 2026, the plan must have a minimum deductible of $1,700 for self-only or $3,400 for family coverage.
Verify your HDHP's out-of-pocket maximum meets IRS limits.
For 2026, the maximum out-of-pocket for an HSA-qualified plan is $8,700 for self-only or $17,400 for family. Plans with higher maximums disqualify you. Check your plan's Summary of Benefits for this figure.
Ensure you are not covered by any other non-HDHP health plan.
Being covered by a spouse's traditional plan, a general-purpose FSA, or Medicare makes you ineligible to contribute to an HSA. This is a common trap for families with dual coverage or individuals nearing retirement.
Determine your correct HSA contribution limit for 2026.
Over-contributing triggers a 6% IRS penalty. For 2026, the limit is $4,400 for self-only HDHP coverage or $8,750 for family coverage. Add $1,000 if you are 55 or older and not enrolled in Medicare. Employer contributions count toward this limit.
Decide if you will make contributions via payroll or directly.
Payroll deductions avoid both federal income tax AND 7.65% FICA (Social Security and Medicare) tax, a major advantage for W-2 employees. Direct contributions are only income-tax deductible. This choice may influence which account you use initially.
Check if your employer offers an HSA with a company contribution.
Free money is the best fee waiver. If your employer contributes to a specific provider's HSA (often Health Equity), it may be worth using that account initially to capture the match, even if you later transfer funds to a preferred provider.
Understand the tax filing requirements (Form 8889).
Whether you choose Health Equity or Fidelity, you are responsible for reporting all HSA contributions and distributions on IRS Form 8889 when you file your taxes. Both providers will send you the necessary tax forms (Form 5498-SA and Form 1099-SA).
Fee Analysis and Cost Projection
Fees are where Health Equity and Fidelity diverge significantly. This section helps you calculate the true cost of each account based on your balance and strategy. A small monthly fee can erode thousands of dollars of potential growth over decades.
Calculate Health Equity's 0.03% monthly custodial fee for your expected balance.
This fee applies to your total account balance, even cash, and is capped at $10 per month ($120 annually). For a $10,000 balance, that's $3 per month or $36 per year. For a $50,000 balance, you hit the $10 monthly cap, paying $120 yearly. This is a direct drag on returns.
Note that Fidelity has $0 monthly maintenance fees for all accounts.
Regardless of your balance--$100 or $100,000--you pay no account maintenance fee. This makes Fidelity uniquely attractive for those who want to keep significant cash on hand for medical expenses without paying for the privilege.
Factor in Fidelity's 0.35% annual investment management fee for balances over $25k.
This fee only applies if you use Fidelity's professional portfolio management services for balances above $25,000. If you self-direct your investments (choose your own funds), this fee is $0. For DIY investors, Fidelity's cost remains zero.
Project the impact of Health Equity's lower interest rates on cash.
Health Equity's tiered rates (0.10% under $2,000, 0.20% on amounts $2,000-$7,500) are generally lower than Fidelity's cash sweep (up to 0.5% APY). On a $5,000 cash balance, this difference could mean $25 less in interest per year at Health Equity.
Inquire about hidden fees for paper statements, debit card replacements, or closures.
Both providers may charge incidental fees. Health Equity often charges a closure/transfer fee. Fidelity may charge for expedited mailings or wire transfers. Knowing these helps avoid unexpected costs during account management.
Compare the fee structure if you plan to invest a small amount immediately.
For a $1,000 account you want to invest, Health Equity's $500 investment threshold is lower than some employer group thresholds. However, you'd still pay their monthly fee on the invested balance. Fidelity has no minimum and no fee, making it cheaper for small, active investors.
Estimate total annual costs for a blended cash/investment strategy.
If you keep $2,000 in cash for bills and invest $10,000, Health Equity charges a monthly fee on the full $12,000. Fidelity charges $0. This simple math often makes Fidelity the cheaper option for most individuals not receiving an employer fee subsidy.
Investment Options and Growth Strategy
An HSA is a powerful long-term investment vehicle. Your provider determines your access to the market. This checklist helps you align your investment goals with the capabilities of Health Equity's limited fund menu versus Fidelity's full brokerage platform.
Verify Health Equity's investment threshold for your specific account.
For individual accounts opened directly, the threshold is $500. For employer-sponsored groups, it can range from $0 to $2,500. You must keep this minimum in cash before you can invest any additional funds. Check your plan documents or call customer service.
Review the list of ~23 Vanguard funds available in Health Equity's self-directed window.
Your choices are restricted to this pre-selected menu of mutual funds, which includes total market, bond, and international index funds. While they are low-cost Vanguard funds, you cannot buy ETFs, individual stocks, or funds from other families like Fidelity or Schwab.
Confirm that Fidelity requires $0 minimum to start investing.
You can invest your first dollar at Fidelity. There is no cash threshold to meet. This allows for immediate dollar-cost averaging and is ideal for those who want to invest most of their contributions right away, maximizing time in the market.
Explore Fidelity's full brokerage capabilities: ETFs, stocks, mutual funds, bonds.
Fidelity's HSA is a full brokerage account. You can build any portfolio you want, including popular low-cost ETFs from iShares or Vanguard, Fidelity's own ZERO fee index funds, or even individual company stocks. This offers maximum control and flexibility.
Evaluate if Health Equity's 'advisor-managed' option is worth the cost.
This managed portfolio service often requires a $2,000 minimum and charges an additional advisory fee. For most savvy investors, a simple three-fund portfolio using the available Vanguard funds in the self-directed window is a cheaper and equally effective strategy.
Plan your asset allocation across HSA and other retirement accounts.
Because HSAs offer triple tax advantages, consider placing assets with the highest expected growth potential (like stock index funds) here. Use your 401(k) or IRA for bonds or other assets. This optimizes your overall tax efficiency.
Set up automatic investments for future contributions.
Whether with Health Equity or Fidelity, automate your plan. Direct new contributions to sweep into your chosen investments automatically. This removes emotion and ensures you are consistently building your healthcare retirement fund.
Account Management and User Experience
Daily usability, customer service, and tools impact how effectively you use your HSA. This section compares the practical experience of managing expenses, accessing funds, and getting help from each provider.
Test the mobile app for both providers for expense tracking and receipt upload.
Health Equity's app is often tailored for HSA-specific tasks like categorizing medical transactions and storing receipt images. Fidelity's app is a powerful general investing tool but may lack specialized HSA features. Choose based on your need for integrated healthcare tracking.
Compare the process for getting reimbursed for qualified expenses.
Both allow debit card payments or manual reimbursements. Health Equity may offer more guidance on eligible expenses at point-of-sale. Fidelity's process is straightforward but places more onus on you to know the rules. Speed of transfers and ease of interface matter here.
Check the integration with your existing financial accounts (if any).
If you already bank or invest with Fidelity, adding an HSA there provides a unified dashboard. If your employer's benefits portal is linked to Health Equity, that integration can simplify payroll contributions and viewing your total benefits package.
Research customer service channels and wait times for HSA-specific questions.
Fidelity is known for strong general customer service. Health Equity's support is specialized for HSAs but can have longer wait times. Try calling both with a pre-prepared question to gauge responsiveness and expertise before you commit.
Understand the rules and timelines for trustee-to-trustee transfers.
If you plan to use an employer Health Equity account but transfer to Fidelity, you need to know the process. Transfers can take 2-6 weeks. You are limited to one indirect rollover per 12 months, so trustee-to-trustee direct transfers are the preferred method.
Review the annual tax reporting documents each provider generates.
Both will send Form 5498-SA (contributions) and Form 1099-SA (distributions). Ensure you understand how to read these and that they are available digitally in a timely manner. Errors on these forms can complicate your tax filing.
Bookmark IRS Publication 502 and 969 for ongoing reference.
No provider is responsible for your compliance. IRS Pub 502 lists eligible medical expenses, and Pub 969 outlines HSA rules. Having these resources handy helps you answer tough questions about expenses like acupuncture, home improvements for medical care, or weight-loss programs.
When You Complete This Checklist
By completing this health equity vs fidelity hsa checklist, you will have a clear, personalized action plan to select the HSA custodian that minimizes fees, maximizes your investment potential, and aligns with your healthcare and financial goals. You'll move forward with confidence, knowing you've made a data-driven choice that could save you thousands over the lifetime of your account.
Pro Tips
- Initiate transfers from the receiving institution (Fidelity) to pull funds from Health Equity. This 'pull' method is often faster and has a lower chance of error than asking Health Equity to 'push' the money out.
- If you have an existing Health Equity HSA, check if your employer has a group fee waiver. Your fees might be paid by your company, making Health Equity a viable option while employed, with a plan to transfer out upon leaving.
- Use your HSA as a stealth retirement account. After age 65, you can withdraw funds for any reason (not just medical) and only pay ordinary income tax, making it function like a 401(k). Prioritize investment growth with this long-term strategy in mind.
- Even if you invest most of your HSA, always keep your current year's insurance deductible in cash. This ensures you can cover a medical emergency without having to sell investments at a potential loss.
- If you are over 55 and making catch-up contributions, remember you cannot contribute to an HSA if you are enrolled in Medicare. Time your Medicare enrollment to maximize your final HSA contributions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is my HSA money safe if Fidelity or Health Equity goes bankrupt?
Yes, your HSA funds are protected. Both Fidelity and Health Equity are custodians, not owners, of your assets. Your cash is held in FDIC-insured bank accounts (up to applicable limits), and your investments are held in your name in a separate brokerage account. Even if the custodian company fails, your assets are not part of their corporate estate and are safe from their creditors.
Can I have both a Health Equity HSA (from my employer) and a Fidelity HSA at the same time?
Yes, you can have multiple HSA accounts. However, your total contributions across all HSAs must not exceed the annual IRS limits ($4,400 for self-only or $8,750 for family in 2026, plus a $1,000 catch-up if 55+). Many people use an employer-sponsored Health Equity account for payroll deductions (to avoid FICA taxes) and then periodically transfer funds to a Fidelity HSA for better investment options and lower fees.
If I leave my job, what happens to my employer-sponsored Health Equity HSA?
Your HSA belongs to you, not your employer. If you leave your job, you keep the Health Equity account and all funds in it. However, your employer may stop paying any monthly maintenance fees they were covering. You can leave the account at Health Equity (and pay their fees), roll it over to a provider like Fidelity to avoid fees, or spend the funds on qualified medical expenses.
Does Fidelity offer any tools to help track HSA-eligible expenses?
Fidelity provides basic transaction categorization and year-end summaries, but their tools are not as specialized for healthcare expense tracking as some dedicated HSA providers. You may need to manually save receipts or use a third-party app. Health Equity often provides integrated expense tracking and receipt upload features, which can simplify record-keeping for IRS audits.
Are there any transfer or rollover fees when moving from Health Equity to Fidelity?
Fidelity does not charge a fee to open an HSA or to receive a transfer. Health Equity, however, typically charges a closure fee (often around $25) when you transfer the entire account out. They may also charge a transfer fee per transaction. Before initiating a transfer, contact Health Equity to confirm their current fee schedule to avoid surprises.
Which provider is better for keeping my HSA in cash for near-term medical bills?
Fidelity is the clear winner for cash holdings. They charge $0 monthly fees regardless of balance, and their cash sweep earns up to 0.5% APY. Health Equity charges a 0.03% monthly custodial fee (capped at $10) even on cash, and their interest rates start at just 0.10% for balances under $2,000. For an emergency medical fund, Fidelity's structure preserves more of your money.
Can I buy individual stocks in my Health Equity HSA?
No. Health Equity's self-directed investment window is restricted to a select menu of about 23 low-cost Vanguard mutual funds. You cannot buy individual stocks, ETFs, or bonds outside that menu. If you want true brokerage access to the full market, Fidelity's HSA provides that, treating your HSA like any other investment account with access to thousands of funds, ETFs, and stocks.
Related Resources
More HSA Resources
FSA vs HSA: Which to Choose
Side-by-side comparison with worked dollar examples for 2026
HSA-Eligible Expenses
See 191+ expenses you can pay with your HSA
What Is an HSA?
Complete guide to Health Savings Accounts
2026 Contribution Limits
See how much you can contribute this year
HSA Calculators
Tax savings, shoebox growth, and more
Check off your HSA tasks
Stay on top of your HSA with smart expense tracking. Never miss a deduction.
Open Dashboard