Schwab Brokerage Account vs Devenir Guided Portfolio
Choosing between Lively's two investment paths can save you hundreds in fees or unlock earlier investing. The Schwab brokerage offers self-directed control, while the Devenir Guided Portfolio provides automated management. Your decision hinges on your balance, investing confidence, and willingness to pay for convenience. This comparison breaks down the exact costs and rules for Lively HSA investment options to help you pick the right path for your tax-advantaged healthcare dollars.
Schwab Brokerage Account
Lively's Schwab brokerage option provides a self-directed investment window into a Charles Schwab Health Savings Brokerage Account. You have full control to buy and sell stocks, ETFs, and mutual funds.
Devenir Guided Portfolio
The Devenir HSA Guided Portfolio is a professionally managed investment service. After answering questions about your goals and risk tolerance, Devenir constructs and maintains a diversified portfolio of ETFs for you. The annual management fee is 0.50% of assets, charged quarterly.
| Feature | Schwab Brokerage Account | Devenir Guided Portfolio |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Management Fee | $24 or $3,000 cash minimumWinner | 0.50% on invested assets |
| Investment Control | Full self-directed controlTie | Automated, managed portfolioTie |
| Minimum to Start Investing | $3,000 cash or $24 fee | No stated minimumWinner |
| Fee Structure Clarity | Simple, predictable annual feeWinner | Percentage-based, scales with balance |
| Portfolio Customization | Unlimited choices via SchwabWinner | Limited to Devenir's model portfolios |
| Ease of Use & Setup | Requires investor knowledge and activity | Simple questionnaire, fully automatedWinner |
| Best for Small Balances (<$3,000) | Costly due to fee percentage | More cost-effective accessWinner |
| Best for Large Balances (>$15,000) | Very low fee as a percentageWinner | Fee grows with account size |
| Tax Efficiency Management | Investor responsibility | Handled by Devenir within portfolioWinner |
| Integration with Lively Cash | Clear $3,000 threshold rule | No cash minimum, fluid integrationWinner |
Our Verdict
Choosing between Lively's Schwab and Devenir investment options depends primarily on your account size and investing style. For hands-on investors with balances over $5,000, the Schwab brokerage is the clear winner on cost, offering lower fees and greater control.
Best for: Schwab Brokerage Account
- Self-directed investors comfortable picking funds
- Individuals with larger HSA balances seeking lowest costs
- Those using the HSA as a long-term retirement supplement
- Investors who want to mirror their IRA or 401(k) strategy
Best for: Devenir Guided Portfolio
- New HSA users with small starting balances
- Investors who prefer completely hands-off management
- People intimidated by choosing their own investments
- Those who value simplicity over maximizing cost savings
Pro Tips
- If your HSA balance is under $3,000 and you want to invest, calculate the $24 fee as a percentage of your portfolio. On a $1,000 balance, that's a 2.4% fee, which may make the Devenir 0.50% fee cheaper initially.
- Use the HSA as a retirement vehicle by investing aggressively early. The 2026 family contribution limit is $8,750, plus a $1,000 catch-up if you're 55+. This can build a significant tax-free sum for future healthcare.
- Check if your employer's HSA provider allows transfers to Lively. You can contribute via payroll to your employer's plan for FICA tax savings, then periodically transfer funds to Lively to access their investment options.
- The IRS allows you to pay for qualified medical expenses from any source and reimburse yourself from the HSA later. Keep receipts and let investments grow tax-free for years before taking a tax-free withdrawal.
- If you choose the Schwab option and pay the $24 fee for first-dollar investing, remember to invest the $3,000 you would have kept in cash. That cash earning 0.12% APY loses to inflation.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between Lively's Schwab and Devenir investment options?
Lively offers two distinct investment platforms. The Schwab brokerage account is a self-directed brokerage window where you choose and manage your own investments from a full menu of stocks, ETFs, and mutual funds. The Devenir HSA Guided Portfolio is a managed service where Devenir builds and rebalances a portfolio of ETFs for you based on a risk questionnaire. The key difference is control versus convenience, reflected in their fee structures and access requirements.
How much does it cost to invest with Lively HSA?
Lively's basic HSA has no monthly fees. Investing adds costs. For the Schwab option, you pay a $24 annual fee unless you maintain a $3,000 minimum cash balance in your Lively account. For the Devenir Guided Portfolio, you pay an annual management fee of 0.50% on your invested assets, deducted quarterly. There is no cash minimum for Devenir. You also need a high-deductible health plan to contribute to any HSA.
Can I start investing in my Lively HSA with a small balance?
Yes, but your options are limited by balance size. The Devenir Guided Portfolio has no stated minimum to start investing, so you could theoretically invest a small amount, though the 0.50% fee would eat into small gains. For the Schwab brokerage, you can only invest dollars above a $3,000 cash balance unless you choose to pay the $24 annual fee, which enables first-dollar investing with no cash minimum required.
Is my money safe in Lively HSA investment accounts?
Safety depends on the vehicle. Cash held in Lively's FDIC-insured sweep account is insured up to applicable limits. Money moved to the Schwab brokerage is invested in securities like stocks and ETFs, which are not FDIC insured and can lose value. The Devenir Guided Portfolio also invests in market-based ETFs, carrying similar investment risk. Neither investment option guarantees principal protection, unlike the insured cash account.
Which Lively investment option is better for long-term retirement savings?
For long-term savers focused on maximizing growth, the Schwab brokerage often has the edge due to lower potential costs. While it may have a $24 fee, a large portfolio invested in low-cost index funds could have a total expense ratio well below 0.50%. The Devenir 0.50% fee, while convenient, adds up significantly over decades. Self-employed individuals or families maximizing contributions for retirement may prefer the control and lower fee structure of Schwab.
Can I switch between Lively's investment options later?
Yes, you can change your strategy. You can have both options linked to your single Lively HSA, but your money can only be in one place at a time. To switch from Devenir to Schwab, you would need to sell the Guided Portfolio holdings, transfer the cash back to your Lively cash account, and then move it to Schwab. This could trigger tax implications if done within the HSA, so it's best to consult Lively directly on the transfer process.
How do Lively's investment fees compare to Fidelity's?
Lively's managed option is more expensive. The Devenir Guided Portfolio charges 0.50% annually. A 2026 Investopedia comparison notes Fidelity's managed account fee is 0.35%. For self-directed investing, Fidelity has no annual account fees for its HSA brokerage, while Lively's Schwab access has a $24 annual fee unless you keep $3,000 in cash. This makes Fidelity potentially cheaper for both hands-on and hands-off investors, though Lively wins on other fees like account closing.
Related Resources
More HSA Resources
FSA vs HSA: Which to Choose
Side-by-side comparison with worked dollar examples for 2026
HSA-Eligible Expenses
See 191+ expenses you can pay with your HSA
What Is an HSA?
Complete guide to Health Savings Accounts
2026 Contribution Limits
See how much you can contribute this year
HSA Calculators
Tax savings, shoebox growth, and more
Compare your own HSA options
Track and compare your healthcare costs in HSA Trackr. See where your money goes.
Start Tracking