Lively HSA vs Fidelity HSA
The verdict
The better provider depends heavily on how you plan to use your HSA. For individuals who prioritize a user-friendly interface with built-in expense tracking and will maintain a $3,000 cash buffer, Lively's $0 monthly fee official offer is strong.
A zero-dollar monthly fee sounds perfect, but is it the whole story? For W2 employees and self-employed individuals choosing an HSA provider, the official pricing page is the starting point. However, the real cost picture includes investment fees, employer plans, and minimum balance rules. This comparison breaks down the official lively hsa monthly fee official details for 2026 against a major competitor, Fidelity, to show where hidden costs might appear for your specific situation.
Lively HSA
Lively HSA offers a compelling $0 monthly fee structure for individual and family accounts, with transparent pricing on its official site. Their platform includes integrated expense tracking and receipt storage tools.
Fidelity HSA
Fidelity HSA is a full-service financial institution known for its investment platform. It also charges $0 monthly maintenance fees for individual accounts. A key differentiator is its approach to investing: there are typically no additional account fees or minimum balances required to start
| Feature | Lively HSA | Fidelity HSA |
|---|---|---|
| Individual Monthly Maintenance Fee | $0Tie | $0Tie |
| Employer Plan Per-Employee Monthly Fee | $2.95 (with $200 min) | $0 typicallyWinner |
| Fee to Start Investing | $24 annual fee unless $3,000 cash | $0, no minimumWinner |
| Managed Portfolio Annual Fee | 0.50% | Varies by fund, often lowerWinner |
| Account Closure Fee | $0Tie | $0Tie |
| Integrated Expense Tracking | Yes, with receipt uploadWinner | Basic transaction listing |
| Debit Card Availability | Up to 3 cards, $0 feeTie | Available, $0 feeTie |
| Excess Contribution Fee | $0Tie | $0Tie |
| Quality of Investment Platform | Schwab portal or guided option | Full Fidelity brokerage platformWinner |
Our Verdict
The better provider depends heavily on how you plan to use your HSA. For individuals who prioritize a user-friendly interface with built-in expense tracking and will maintain a $3,000 cash buffer, Lively's $0 monthly fee official offer is strong.
Best for: Lively HSA
- Individuals who want integrated tools for tracking medical receipts and expenses.
- Savers who can maintain a $3,000 cash balance to waive Lively's investment fee.
- Those who prefer a guided, managed portfolio option for their HSA investments.
Best for: Fidelity HSA
- Investors who want to start investing small balances immediately with no extra fees.
- Employers and HR managers seeking to minimize administrative costs for company HSA plans.
- Financial advisors and savvy savers who want a full brokerage platform with extensive fund choices.
Pro Tips
- If your HSA balance is below $3,000 and you want to invest with Lively, consider saving until you hit that cash threshold to avoid the $24 annual Schwab fee, or look at providers with no investment minimums.
- HR managers comparing providers should calculate the true cost of Lively's $200 monthly minimum. For a small business with 30 employees, the effective per-employee cost rises from $2.95 to about $6.67 per month.
- Use the last-month rule cautiously. If you become HSA-eligible in December 2026 and contribute the full annual limit, you must maintain HDHP coverage for all of 2027 to avoid penalties and tax recapture.
- For family coverage, remember the 2026 contribution limit is $8,750. If both spouses have separate HSA accounts, this limit is a shared total, not per account.
- Scan your pharmacy receipts. Many OTC medications and menstrual care products are now HSA-eligible, but the receipt must clearly show the eligible item to satisfy IRS documentation rules.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Lively HSA really free for individuals?
Yes, for individual and family accounts opened directly, Lively's monthly maintenance fee is $0. Their support page confirms this, and their pricing lists $0 for account opening, closing, debit cards, and transfers. The main cost for individual users appears only if you choose to invest and select certain investment options, like the Schwab self-directed account which has a $24 annual fee unless you maintain a $3,000 cash balance.
How much does a Lively HSA cost if my employer offers it?
The pricing structure changes for employer-sponsored plans. Lively's published business pricing is $2.95 per enrolled employee per month, with a $200 monthly minimum. This means if your company has fewer than about 68 employees, the cost per employee is effectively higher to meet that minimum. Employees typically do not pay this fee directly; it is an administrative cost for the employer.
What are the investment fees with Lively?
Lively offers two primary investment paths. The self-directed option through Schwab carries a $24 annual fee, waived if you keep at least $3,000 in your HSA cash account. Their Guided Portfolio by Devenir charges a 0.50% annual management fee, billed quarterly. This means for a $10,000 invested balance, you'd pay about $50 per year for the managed portfolio.
How does Fidelity's HSA pricing compare to Lively's?
Fidelity also offers $0 monthly maintenance fees for individual accounts. Unlike Lively, Fidelity generally has no account minimums or extra fees to start investing. For employer plans, Fidelity often remains fee-free for the business as well, which can be a significant difference from Lively's $2.95 per employee per month model.
Should I worry about the IRS auditing my HSA expenses?
Proper record-keeping is your best defense. The IRS requires you to keep receipts for all HSA distributions you claim as qualified medical expenses. Using your HSA debit card for ineligible purchases can trigger penalties and taxes. Providers like Lively offer expense tracking tools, but the ultimate responsibility for proving eligibility lies with you, the account holder.
Can I use my HSA for Direct Primary Care (DPC) in 2026?
According to Lively's published 2026 guidance, Direct Primary Care (DPC) arrangements are eligible HSA expenses up to specified monthly limits. This is a change that benefits those using this healthcare model. You can pay your DPC monthly fees from your HSA without it affecting your HDHP qualification, as long as the amounts stay within the limits set by the IRS.
What happens if I over-contribute to my HSA?
Excess contributions are subject to a 6% IRS penalty tax each year they remain in the account. Lively charges a $0 fee for processing an excess contribution removal or return, but you must still correct the error and report it on your taxes. It's important to track your contributions, especially if you switch HDHP coverage mid-year or have contributions from both you and your employer.
Related Resources
More HSA Resources
FSA vs HSA: Which to Choose
Side-by-side comparison with worked dollar examples for 2026
HSA-Eligible Expenses
See 191+ expenses you can pay with your HSA
What Is an HSA?
Complete guide to Health Savings Accounts
2026 Contribution Limits
See how much you can contribute this year
HSA Calculators
Tax savings, shoebox growth, and more
Compare your own HSA options
Track and compare your healthcare costs in HSA Trackr. See where your money goes.
Start Tracking